Paint or not paint?

I only brought a few pieces of furniture with me on our recent move. One of those pieces is a 10' tall antique pine armoire. I loved this piece in our beach home but it just doesn't seem to fit in our new traditional Virginia home. I had thought of painting the armoire...maybe a creamy white with smoke glaze.  I could paint it black for a traditional look. I had almost decided to go ahead and paint it when this catalog arrived:

I am loving all this natural wood

Thank you Restoration Hardware.  You have made me fall in love again with the unfinished pine armoire.

This is my armoire in unfinished pine.

This is the family room and the armoire is on the left wall.

So, should I paint or not? I would love your suggestions.